The Soul: Why Medical Practitioners and Islamic Scholars Do Not Accept Brain Death Concept

Nor Aina Mohd Khotib, Universiti Utara Malaysia
Noor Naemah Abdul Rahman, University of Malaya
Shaikh Mohd Saifuddeen, Institute of Islamic Understanding Malaysia


Abstract


The concept of brain death refers to the irreversible loss of brain function which includes the brain stem. The diagnosis of brain death is a controversial issue among Muslim scholars and medical experts because it involves the pronouncement of death of a patient whose heart is still beating with the assistance of a ventilator (breathing apparatus). Many countries recognise brain death as true death. However, there are religious scholars and medical experts who disagree with the concept of brain death because they believe that the soul still exists in one’s body although the brain has been diagnosed as dead. From their point of view, the heartbeat shows that the soul is still present in the body. From the perspective of Islam, a person is considered dead when there is separation between the soul and body. This paper will discuss the arguments pertaining to the soul which have been used in rejecting the concept and diagnosis of brain death.


Keywords


Brain death, cardiac death, death, soul, medical practitioner, ventilator.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abdulla, Ra-id, G. A. Blew, and M. J. Holterman. “Cardiovascular Embryology.” Pediatric Cardiology 25, no. 3 (2004): 191–200.

Abu Sa‘dah, Muhammad Husayni. al-Nafs wa Khulūduhā ‘ind Fakhr al-Dīn al-Rāzī. Cairo: Sharikah al-Safa li al-Taba‘ah wa al-Tarjumah wa al-Nashr, 1989.

Al-Attar, Besher et al. “Brain Death and Organ Donation in Saudi Arabia.” Transplantation Proceedings 33, no. 5 (2001): 2629–2631.

Bedir, Ahmet, and Şahin Aksoy. “Brain Death Revisited: It is not ‘Complete Death’ according to Islamic Sources.” Journal of Medical Ethics 37, no. 5 (2011): 290–294.

Bernat, James L., Charles M. Culver, and Bernard Gert. “On the Definition and Criterion of Death.” Annals of Internal Medicine 94, no. 3 (1981): 389–394.

Boobes, Yousef, and Nada Al Daker. “What it Means to Die in Islam and Modern Medicine.” Saudi Journal of Kidney Diseases and Transplantation 7, no. 2 (1996): 121.

Bowman, Kerry W., and Shawn A. Richard. “Culture, Brain Death, and Transplantation.” Progress in Transplantation 13, no. 3 (2003): 211–217.

Consensus Statement on Brain Death. Ministry of Health, Academy of Medicine of Malaysia and Malaysian Society of Neuroscience. Putrajaya: Ministry of Health, Academy of Medicine of Malaysia, Malaysian Society of Neuroscience, 2003.

Daar, Abdallah S. “The Response to the Challenge of Organ Shortage in the Middle East Region: A Summary.” In Transplantation Proceedings 8, no. 29 (1997): 3215–3216.

“Definition of Irreversible Coma: Report of the Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death.” JAMA 205, no. 6 (1968): 337–340.

Ebrahim, Abul Fadl Mohsin. “Deliberations of Muslim Scholars on the End of Human Life.” In Organ Transplantation Contemporary Islamic Legal and Ethical Perspectives. (Kuala Lumpur: A. S. Noordeen, 1998): 92–99.

______________. “Islamic Jurisprudence and the End of Human Life.” Medicine and Law. 17 (1998): 189–96.

Farah, Samir, and Ashraf Al-Kurdi. “Brain Death: Definition, Medical, Ethical and Islamic Jurisprudence Implications.” In Brain Death: Definition, Medical, Ethical and Islamic Jurisprudence Implications. ed. Hossam E. Fadel, Muhammad A. A. Khan, and Aly A. Mishal. Amman: Jordan Society for Islamic Medical Sciences in collaboration with Federation of Islamic Medical Associations, 2006.

Hamdy, Sherine. “Not quite Dead: Why Egyptian Doctors Refuse the Diagnosis of Death by Neurological Criteria.” Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 34, no. 2 (2013): 147–160.

Haque, Omar Sultan. “Brain Death and its Entanglements: A Redefinition of Personhood for Islamic Ethics.” Journal of Religious Ethics 36, no. 1 (2008): 13–36.

Hooi, Lai Seong and Lela Yasmin Mansor ed. Sixth Report of the National Transplant Registry Malaysia 2009. Kuala Lumpur, 2011.

Ibn Sina, Abu ʿAli al-Husayn bin ʿAbd Allah. Aḥwāl al-Nafs Risālah fī al-Nafs wa Baqā˒ihā wa Maʿadihā wa yalīhā Thalāth Rasā˒il fī al-Nafs li Ibn Sinā. Paris: Dar Babylon, 1952.

Idris, Abd al-Fattah Mahmud. al-Ghaybūbah Al-Dimāghiyyah: Jadal Bayn Al-Atibbā˒ Wa Al-Fuqahā˒. 1st. ed. Riyad: Dar al-Sumay‘i, 2011.

Iqbal, Sajid. “Accepting End of Life Care Realities—When the Choices are Limited.” Journal of Clinical Research & Bioethics 4, no. 4 (2013): 1.

Machado, Calixto. “Diagnosis of Brain Death.” Neurology International 2, no. 1 (2010).

Mohd Rani Jusoh, “Mati Otak: Konsensus Pengamal Perubatan.” In Sempadan Bioteknologi Menurut Perspektif Islam. Edited by Shaikh Mohd Saifuddeen. Kuala Lumpur: Institut Kefahaman Islam Malaysia (IKIM), 2005.

Al-Mousawi, M., T. Hamed, and H. Al-Matouk. “Views of Muslim Scholars on Organ Donation and Brain Death.” In Transplantation Proceedings 29, no. 8 (1997): 3217.

Al-Musayyar, Muhammad Sayyid Ahmad. al-Rūḥ fī Dirāsāt al-Mutakallimīn wa al-Falāsifah. 3rd. ed. Cairo: Dar al-Ma‘arif, 2002.

Najati, Muhammad Uthman. al-Dirāsāt al-Nafsāniyyah ʿinda al-Ulamā˒ al-Muslimīn. Cairo: Dar al-Shuruq, 1993.

Padela, Aasim I., Ahsan Arozullah, and Ebrahim Moosa. “Brain Death in Islamic Ethico‐Legal Deliberation: Challenges for Applied Islamic Bioethics.” Bioethics 27, no. 3 (2013): 132–139.

Pansky, Ben. Review of Medical Embryology. New York: McMillan, 1982.

Procaccio, F., L. Rizzato, A. Ricci, S. Venettoni, and A. Nanni Costa. “Do ‘Silent’ Brain Deaths Affect Potential Organ Donation?” In Transplantation Proceedings 42, no. 6 (2010): 2190–2191.

Al-Razi, Fakhr al-Din. Kitāb al-Mabāḥith al-Mashriqiyyah fī ʿIlm al-Ilāhiyyāt wa al-Ṭabīʿiyyāt. Hyderabad: Maṭbaʿah Majlis Dā’irah al-Ma‘ārif al-Niẓāmiyyah, 1922.

_____________. al-Nafs wa al-Rūḥ wa Sharḥ Quwā humā. Edited by Muhammad Saghir Hasan al-Maʿsumi. Islamabad: Maʿhad al-Abḥāth al-Islamiyyah, 1968.

Shaikh Mohd Saifuddeen Shaikh Mohd Salleh et al. “Pemindahan Organ dari Perspektif Islam.” 1st. ed. Putrajaya: Kementerian Kesihatan Malaysia and Jabatan Kemajuan Islam Malaysia, 2011.

Sheerani, Mughis et al. “Brain Death: Concepts and Knowledge amongst Health Professionals in the Province of Sindh, Pakistan.” Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association 58, no. 7 (2008): 352.

Al-Shirbini, Shams al-Din Muhammad bin Muhammad al-Khatib. Mughnī Al-Muḥtāj Ilā Maʿrifat Maʿānī Alfāẓ Al-Minḥāj. Ed. Muhammad Muhammad Tamir and Sharif ‘Abdullah. Cairo: Dār al-Ḥadīth, 2006.

Siminoff, Laura A., Christopher Burant, and Stuart J. Youngner. “Death and Organ Procurement: Public beliefs and Attitudes.” Social Science & Medicine 59, no. 11 (2004): 2325–2334.

Sixth National Transplant Registry Malaysia 2009. http://www.mst.org.my/ntrsite/donwload/report2009/6thNTRreport2009.pdf.

Spoor, Martin T., and Francis R. Sutherland. “The Evolution of the Concept of Brain Death.” Annals (Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada) 28, no. 1 (1995): 30–34.

Wahab, Siraj. “Expert Calls for New Fatwa on Brain Dead.” Saudi Arabia, 29 September 2010. http://www.arabnews.com/node/356370.

Wijdicks, Eelco F.M. “Brain Death Worldwide: Accepted Fact but no Global Consensus in Diagnostic Criteria.” Neurology 58, no. 1 (2002): 20–25.

Zaki Morad Mohd. Zaher. “Organ Transplantation”. In Guideline of the Malaysian Medical Council (MMC Guideline 006/2006). Kuala Lumpur: Malaysian Medical Council, 2006. http://mmc.gov.my/images/contents/ethics/Organ-Transplantation.pdf


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.